President Barack Obama's Leadership Style - Repudiated at the 2010 Midterm Elections?

73

By ecoggins

Where's the Change?

President Obama Humbled but Not Despised

On November 2, 2010, the citizens of the United States of America cast their votes and seemed to repudiate American President Barack Obama's leadership style including his policies. Indeed, in a historic turn of events the Republican party regained control of the House of Representatives and made significant gains in the United States Senate and State Governorships across the country as well.

These results seem to coincide with an amateur poll I have been running since August 2010 in another hub called 10 Reasons Why American President Barack Obama May or May Not Be Re-elected in 2012.

In that poll I asked a number of questions about President Obama and the job he has done since taking the White House in January 2009. So far, 43 of 231 visitors have chosen to participate in the poll. Here are the results as of November 4, 2010:

President Barack Obama Not Expected to Be Re-elected in 2012

My first question was "do you think President Obama will be re-elected in 2012"? 63% said No; 26% answered Yes; and 12% replied "I'm not sure."

The second question was similar but went more to the participants personal preference; I asked "do you think President Obama should be re-elected in 2012"? 60% said No; 30% said Yes; and 7% chose to "plead the 5th".

President Barack Obama Not Seen as Keeping Campaign Promises

The third poll question concerning President Obama's leadership style asked: "do you think President Obama has attempted to keep his campaign promises?" Of 39 people who answered 62% said No; while the other 38% answered Yes.

President Barack Obama Not Seen as Improving America's Image around the World

The fourth poll question in 10 Reasons Why President Barack Obama May or May Not Be Re-elected in 2012 asked about Obama's impact on foreign policy and foreign relations. Many experts in the American Presidency acknowledge that the United States' Head of State is virtually powerless when it comes to domestic policy and that his main purpose is to head up American foreign policy and foreign relations. Indeed, at the beginning of his presidency Obama received many accolades for how he softened America's image around the world. However in recent days due to the war in Afghanistan and other issues with China, many have come to see him as weak in this area. When asked if people thought President Obama has improved America's image around the world, so far 63% of 41 participants answered No and 37% answered Yes.

President Barack Obama Seen As Presidential

In the fifth question I asked: "Do you think President Obama looks presidential?" With the above answers, I would have anticipated that the larger number of participants in my little survey were either Republicans or Libertarian independents who dislike Obama and thus have skewed the results of this small poll. But the results from this question tell me that this is not necessarily the case. Surprisingly, of 41 people who answered question number 5, 52% believe President Obama does in fact look presidential. This tells me that a number of the Democrats who participated in the poll are also displeased with President Obama's job and leaderstyle thus far. Moreover, Republicans and Libertarians do not seem to hate Obama just because he is a Democrat. At least some are willing to admit that he looks good in the Oval Office, but they truly disagree with his policies.

President Barack Obama Seen as Weak in National Defense

The sixth question concerning President Obama's leadership style asked: "How would you rate President Obama on national defense?" Not surprisingly, 58% answered "mostly unfavorable" or somewhat unfavorable while 42% said Mostly or somewhat favorable. However, this was not really an issue in the 2010 midterm elections.

President Barack Obama Not Seen as Changing Washington

Questions 7 and 8 in my amateur poll asked if people thought President Obama had kept his promise to curtail actitvities of special interest groups in Washington and how they would rate President Obama's attempt how Washington operates. In both cases, those who answered feli overwhelmingly that he had not kept his promise to curtail special interest groups and rated his effort to change Washington as mostly unfavorable. Of those who answered 86% felt President Barack Obama had not curtailed special interests at all.

President Barack Obama's Position on the Mosque at Ground Zero Rejected

The ninth question asked whether participants agreed with the President's position concerning the Mosque at Ground Zero. 69% of the 39 who took the poll said they did not agree with the President's position concerning the mosque.

President Barack Obama Not Seen as Doing Enough to Create Jobs.

The last question asked the one question everyone knows the answer to...it's the economy stupid. In the 10th and final question I asked: 'Has President Obama done enough to create jobs?" The overwhelming response has thus far been a resounding and emphatic "No!". And this is probably the biggest reason for the repudiation of President Barack Obama's leadership style in the 2010 midterm elections. People are out of work and they have not seen any movement towards creating jobs in the private sector.

Surprisingly reasonable voters across the board seem to believe President Obama looks good behind the desk in the Oval Office, but not surprisingly his inability to jump start the economy and create jobs left him with egg on his face after the 2010 midterm elections.

Comments

breakfastpop profile image

breakfastpop Level 8 Commenter 18 months ago

He has no leadership skills nor is he interested in acquiring them. He should have remained in Chicago.

dahoglund profile image

dahoglund Level 7 Commenter 18 months ago

I do not think he really understands what leadership is.None of his training or experience were in leadership roles.

KenWu profile image

KenWu 18 months ago

I don't follow the news about Barack Obama news so no comment about his leadership skill. One thing to note (I might be wrong here) here is that when he took over the states presidency, the country is already facing a lot of problems and that take a lot or effort to rectify. By the way, he got a really good oratory skills.

ecoggins profile image

ecoggins Hub Author 18 months ago

breakfastpop and dahoglund, I appreciate your contributions, even if I don't necessarily agree with the sentiment.

ecoggins profile image

ecoggins Hub Author 18 months ago

KenWu, you are very much right. The American economy was extremely complicated mess when President Obama took office. No one could have turned it around in only two years. However, he probably should have made job creation his first priority and then moved to other issues on his agenda. When behind the teleprompter he does look and sound good, but he has problems when he tries to speak off the top of his head.

The most admirable point of Obama's presidency thus far is that he has attempted to fulfill many of his campaign promises. He said he would attempt to pass a healthcare reform bill and he has even if it is only part of what he wanted to accomplish. He said he would end the war in Iraq and focus on the war in Afghanistan and he has. He said he would pass a Wall Street reform bill and he did even if it does not go far enough.

I may not agree that those things were good for the country, but he has attempted to keep his promises and that is admirable.

He is between what we call "a rock and a hard place." Damned if you do and damned if you don't. His greatest failure is he underestimated how entrenched Washington politicians and lobbyists are.

eovery profile image

eovery 18 months ago

So what will stop him from making executive orders to do his dirty work with?

Keep on hubbing!

Joni Douglas profile image

Joni Douglas 18 months ago

Guess we will find out if he knows what true bipartisanship really is now won't we?

KenWu profile image

KenWu 18 months ago

ecoggins - Thanks for the feedback on Mr Obama. Hope he has plan to keep everything in place.

Dave Sibole profile image

Dave Sibole Level 2 Commenter 18 months ago

His legacy is going to be he never knew or learned how to govern. Good Hub I like polls.

ecoggins profile image

ecoggins Hub Author 18 months ago

Joni - maybe, but it takes too to tango. So far the Republicans in Congress seem more interested in beating him than coming up with real solutions to the nations problems.

KenWu - Your welcome; now he will need to be more than a nice ideal.

Dave - Can you govern the ungovernable? I voted Republican, but where are the Republican solutons to the housing problem and its subsequent economic crisis created under their watch from 2000-2008?

OpinionDuck profile image

OpinionDuck 17 months ago

We need congressional and presidential reform.

Obama is running as a tie with Jimmy Carter as a president, and Jimmy wasn't a good president.

Ken Crow profile image

Ken Crow 16 months ago

Personally speaking, " I THINK THIS PRESIDENT IS A DISASTER ". We are much weaker globally in terms of military. We are weaker financially and we are not respected nor feared. It is but a matter of time before we are hit, and hit hard by financial and militarily by terrorist or another country such as China or worse yet Russia. Oh yes, do not poofoo me. We are weaker and our President is not respected. Most of the major players view him as a joke. Unfortunately it is true. WikiLeaks proved that. I love OpinionDuck and his insight...:-)

ecoggins profile image

ecoggins Hub Author 16 months ago

Ken Crow, thank you for your comments. I appreciate your opinion. The U.S. seems to be weaker militarily because we wasted huge amounts of resources on a war in Iraq that should not have been fought. That war depleted the U.S. of both military and moral capital. China will never attack us because we owe them huge amounts of cash. The only way for them to recover their investment is to keep the U.S. financially strong (I suppose in that case we would be slaves to China). You could be right about Russia, but only because Putin is trying to reinstate an authoritarian regime and wants to prove that Russia is still a superpower. Obama inherited a mess that no President of any consequence could have negotiated us out of in two years. Most of WikiLeaks leaks contained information from well before his term of office. I would like to see evidence that most major players view him as a joke; which major players are you talking about and what quotes do you have to back up the claims?

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working